Monday, December 05, 2016

Trump, Brexit, and Aggregate Demand

A lot has been written about Trump, Brexit, and the so-called revolt against the Davos consensus that's been in place since Clinton (or earlier). All of it may be true, or have some truth to it, but fundamentally the economics problems today stem from a lack of aggregate demand.

I was at an econtalk between Russ Roberts and John Cochrane, and while I was struck by how incidental the usual libertarian talking points sounded, I thought that a point Cochrane made about market size was very insightful. He said "the larger the market, the greater the gains from specialization" which is obviously true. There is something very valuable in large, open, free markets and to lose that is a tragedy.

It's a tragedy happening right now as middle class workers, seeing jobs slip away, are voting for protectionist trade policies. And I'm a Chicago Boy, but still support this.

I support this because I don't see an equally strong fiscal response creating enough demand to generate the new jobs these people can do. Suppose I was willing to pay a 15% premium for a "made in America" product. But my budget constraint means I cannot. If I had more money, I would, as I would consume local manufacture as a consumption good. But taxes are so high that on the margin I end up not doing it.

I think the US can produce high quality products, and I think there is a premium it can capture for local manufacture, but I also think that the population's budget constraint means that that market is too small to employ all those individuals with manufacturing skills who have seen their work go overseas. A larger deficit would meet household's savings demand, relax their budget constraint, and I think drive demand that would help put those who produce tradable domestically back to work.

4 Comments:

Blogger Ramanan said...

Winterspeak,

Suppose I was willing to pay a 15% premium for a "made in America" product. But my budget constraint means I cannot... but I also think that the population's budget constraint means that that market is too small to employ all those individuals with manufacturing skills who have seen their work go overseas.

The policy of tariffs means that the fiscal policy multiplier is larger so that even if the *price* is higher, household incomes are higher too. Workers can be employed domestically since aggregate demand will be higher.

6:37 AM  
Blogger The Arthurian said...

The one thing that economists always miss when calculating the costs and benefits of induced free trade is that it weakens the "state-ness" of the trading partners. No one ever tells us we'll have to sacrifice being American in order to be "free traders", and no economist ever figures into the calculation.

4:07 AM  
Blogger Mark Groom said...

A larger deficit is not necessarily the answer. Tax cuts for the wealthy and corporations will result in a bigger deficit but the result will be more billionaires and the same aggregate demand. What is needed is tax relief for the middle class (eliminate the payroll tax). This would drive aggregate demand up and unemployment down giving workers more bargaining power (a positive feedback system). The resulting fiscal outcome could even be a surplus if business invest more due to the increase in demand.

12:20 PM  
Blogger Irving Bruce said...

In the event that you are living in gurgaon, then you can undoubtedly move your business to somewhere else without worrying by any means. gurgaon is a city in Haryana which is very much joined through railroads and thruways. It is very much connected with Chandigarh and Delhi.

What kind of movie runs its climactic scene under the opening credits? This odd duck does, then embarks on a long flashback leading up to the moment when John Payne gets popped a 22-calibur in the shoulder. Payne is a former cop hired by a wheelchair-bound ne to find a ruby that disappeared in a plane crash in the Caribbean. The actor is his usual reliable self, but his romantic sparring partner, unfortunately, is played by Mary Murphy femme about as fatale as a prom queen, going from bland to shrill with no shadings in between.

Oakleys use a special optical technology that is extremely superior in terms of quality where can i buy cheap ray bans online of vision. There is no distortion in vision, even at the corners of your sunglasses. The best replica Oakley sunglasses fit naturally around the skull. It was useless prada handbags,prada sunglasses to attempt to purchase my admission new balance,new balance to the gallery. My the north face,northface money adidas,adidas superstar was uggs outlet,uggs refused. m a c cosmetics,mac makeup I cheap oakley,cheap oakley sunglasses returned to ugg,uggs the converse shoes,converse sneakers street, coach purses outlet,coach purses outlet online to hollister clothing,hollister clothing store wait omega watches,replica watches for Mrs.

We're not annoyed from a young Nike Shoes For Cheap child that includes wrinkly denim denims. Higher, These guys put Nike Lebron Xi on crease badly as you consider!Great simple princess often where can i get cheap ray bans could be Kevin Durant Shoes Cheap described as 23 months(Lately!) And he or she has a handful of fake oakleys for kids conditions. My mom possess restoration your loved one their dolls right preceding to we are going Nike Basketball Shoes Sale to fall out or a where to buy cheap real ray bans meal.

If they come off fairly easily, take a picture of the keyboard before you remove any more, so you know how to put them all back on. You can also lay them out on a surface, in order, as you take them off. Once you have access beneath the keys, clean all the juice out of the keyboard with damp cloths and/or cotton swabs.

Nike Basketball Sneakers Particularly pleasant electrical liveliness routed in a quality path. In low completely extractible stickers, I came pics including Nike Free launch Nike Running 2 2012 Luz azul prpura Mujeres Precio microsoft Bajo just what exactly leaped keen on all the compartment the kids night stands. Underwear, Often sleeve t-shirts, Sleepwear, And so forth

7:17 PM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home